Chopin Music Forum

[PianistSk8er]

Okay, this could be quite arguable.. which are your favorite interpretations/recordings of these pieces?

For me, I would have to say..

- Zimerman for poetic 'in-touch-with-Chopin' interpretations
- Ashkenazy for VERY interesting interpretations and very neat use of staccato in places I would never have imagined (instead of legato)
- Rubinstein.. gotta love that guy

Your opinions?

(let me know if I should add to the poll)

PS

[aout4]

I haven't heard much of those, but my ears are more familiar with Ashkenazy's Ballades cos I got a cd by him...

same for Scherzo, I got Yundi Li's new cd recently and the interpretation seems good (sorry I don't know how to describe like the way you guys did, so it's "good")

[Scriabinist]

I kind of like Pogorelich and Bolet for Scherzi. Pogo for da FURY and Bolo for da SPEED. Haha, kidding. I like Rubinstein.

For Ballades, I don't really know. Maybe Zimerman or Pollini but that would be just too common choice. >_>

[Max]

I like Pollini for the Ballades, Hough for the Scherzi - in fact, Hough for both (except Pollinis exceptional no.2, the only recording I've heard that has the whole picture of the piece)

[krittyot]

the 4 ballades by Zimerman really command respect from us, don't you peeps think?

[PianistSk8er]

Ever hear Horowitz's Ballades? It pains me to say that I'm less than impressed. =S

Opinions?

[Goldberg]

Rubinstein. I have ALWAYS been partial to Rubinstein's recordings for Chopin, and have listened to a good deal of them (including, obviously, the Ballades and Scherzi). As I've related several times, he was really the first "real" pianist I ever listened to, and at one point I thought that he was like the ONLY pianist in the world, ever (sorry, Cziffra!). Heh, I was very ignorant for about a year after my lessons....and during that time I really only bothered buying Rubinstein's Chopin discs. Now almost anyone else I listen to Chopin--except for a few individual pieces (and the ones Rubinstein didn't record)--seems to irritate me with "odd" rubato, say, or different tempi, phrasing, ornamentation, etc.

I know it's not a good idea to be so close-minded (and really I'm not entirely closed about it), but that's just how it happened, that I have such a developed affinity to Rubinstein!

[Helling]

Well my anti-Horowitz sentiments are rather known and often give rise to discussions, but in any case I must say that Rubinstein is among my favourites for the ballades.

Incidentally, I cannot really bring to mind many really "legendary" pianists having performed the ballades. I know Rachmaninov recorded the third (and it is not my favourite recording of his but it has more to do with the piece than his playing). Also Paderewski recorded the third and fourth, but his interpretations are often looked upon in a rather negative fashion. There is only a piano roll of the former, and a seriously "beyond prime" radio recording of the latter.

No recording from one of my favourites (Rosenthal) either. Not sure about Friedmann but I think he recorded some. And actually I am not completely updated on Cortot - for some reason I cannot recall exactly which ones he has recorded.

Pollini is not bad for a modern Chopin performer, but I always find his interpretations strangely unsatisfying, as if he does not really bring out everything inherent in pieces. But maybe it is just some subconcious discrimination of contemporary pianists.

[Goldberg]

Yeah, I think I know what you mean...

As far as anti-Horowitz sentiments, I think I can sympathise with them in general, and more particularly, I've never been very fond of his Chopin. I'm not sure how deep your sentiments go, however, but I assume I'm probably more fond of him than you are--*although* I don't really listen to him much, except really for Russian music, Beethoven (niether of which I care much for) and Liszt, for whom I have Cziffra...

Anyway, Horowitz's Chopin is just "weird" in my book, but I suppose you can have stranger...

[Sightreader]

Arrau's Chopin recordings always amaze me. Of course I also like Rubinstein and Ashkenazy, and haven't listened to the others but will have to do so.

[Brewtality]

Kissin is on the poll but Cortot isn't? not impressed.
I agree with whats been said about Rubinstein's ballades. I actually prefer his ballade 1 to Hofmann's which had been my favourite until recently. Hofmann's ballade 4 is great, and yeah im a huge Horowitz fan and i like his Chopin.